The Challenge of Scaling Indian Innovation

2:31 PM Monday May 11, 2009
by Anil Gupta

Tags:India, Innovation

gupta-110.jpgDada Khobragade is a farmer living in a small hut without toilets in India. That itself is not unusual. But Dada Khobragade is not an average farmer — he's a farmer/innovator. Khobragade's innovation, a rice variety, known as HMT, has diffused to more than 100,000 acres across India. It is now a standard reference of grain thinness at the National Protection of Plant Variety and Farmers' Rights Authority (PPVFRA) — that means when PPVFRA receives any rice variety for registration, it is measured against Dada Khobragade's variety for grain thinness. And yet despite having created a scalable innovation and a public good, Khobragade has remained on the margin, living in a small hut without toilets.

There are hundreds of such farmer-innovators who have not gotten their due. Khobragade is now getting an Innovation Fellowship from India's National Innovation Foundation (NIF), but thanks to the limited resources at the disposal of the NIF, his story is too common.

For the last nine years, the resources of the NIF remained frozen at about $350,000 USD per annum, a fraction of total funds required. SRISTI, an Indian NGO that helps grassroots inventors, has managed without any external support for the last three years. No major breakthrough is expected until policy makers realize that these innovators deserve better. It's not just about moving them into houses with functioning toilets — these budgetary restrictions mean hundreds, maybe thousands, of other innovations will go unheralded.

The NIF has scouted over 100,000 ideas, both innovations and traditional knowledge, through the voluntary Honey Bee Network. HBN is a voluntary network set up more than twenty years ago which essentially mimics the behavior of honey bees as a metaphor in innovation. All the knowledge and new ideas collected are "cross-pollinated" with other communities and individuals a thousand miles away. HBN believes in protecting the knowledge rights of every knowledge-producer; nobody involved with HBN can earn personal income based on community knowledge unless that income is shared with the community in an explicit, transparent way as explained in our guidelines. Any third party wealth, say by a company which uses knowledge or innovations in HBN, also has to be shared in a fair and just manner. Although the NIF has been able to support only a few of the 100,000 ideas they have uncovered through the network, HBN's size shows just how much grassroots genius is being left on the table.

The traditional private sector has also fallen short when it comes to supporting these entrepreneurs. In this "decade of derivatives" it became harder for small start-ups to attract investment capital. In India, most venture capital firms were investing in the equity of listed companies. Angel fund networks would wait till an innovator had developed a business plan, put together a team, and demonstrated results. Why would that innovator then need an angel fund?

And yet, in the meantime, technologists, entrepreneurs, and innovators are finding ways to work around the institutional barriers. For instance, a web portal (techpedia.sristi.org) being set up by SRISTI with the help of the Computer Society of India and TEPP of DSIR should improve the situation (see sristi.org/anilg for details) by pooling 600,000 projects done by technology students in India every year. If even one percent of these become legitimate new products, we will get 6,000 new products every year.

But we could be doing so much more. I wish 10 percent of the stimulus funds for reviving our economies were being spent on the ideas and innovations of young people to generate innovation-based enterprises. We have to find more ways to link innovation with investment with enterprise — that's the golden triangle for grassroots creativity.

Grassroots innovations can provide a new ray of hope, provided we help them grow. Outside of India's major cities, unsung heroes of the country are solving, or trying to solve, local problems in spite of the structures that have bypassed them so far. Creativity, compassion and collaboration are the key characteristics of these voices from grassroots. Let us listen to them and resonate with them.

Remember: minds on the margins are not marginal minds.

Anil Gupta is Executive Vice Chair, National Innovation Foundation and Professor, Indian Institute of Management.

People who read this also read:

People Who Like This Also Like
 
* * *
Sign up for the Harvard Business Publishing Weekly Hotlist, a new weekly email roundup featuring the top highlights from HarvardBusiness.org.


Trackbacks

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.harvardbusiness.org/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4120

No trackbacks have been made to this entry.

Join The Discussion

* Required Fields




Verification (needed to reduce spam):


Get a new challenge
Get an audio challengeGet a visual challenge
Help

Posting Guidelines

We hope the conversations that take place on HarvardBusiness.org will be energetic, constructive, free-wheeling, and provocative. To make sure we all stay on-topic, all posts will be reviewed by our editors and may be edited for clarity, length, and relevance.

We ask that you adhere to the following guidelines.

  1. No selling of products or services. Let's keep this an ad-free zone.
  2. No ad hominem attacks. These are conversations in which we debate ideas. Criticize ideas, not the people behind them.
  3. No multimedia. If you want us to know about outside sources, please point to them, Don't paste them in.
We look forward to including your voices on the site - and learning from you in the process.

The editors

Conversation Starter

Behind the breaking business news is often a management idea gone right or wrong. That’s where the Conversation Starter comes in. With this blog, we hope to shed new light on major events and trends in the business world by helping unearth the bigger ideas at work and discussing how those ideas are shaping our lives every day. We hope you'll join the conversation.

Protect your company and your career with a subscription to Harvard Business Review.
Harvard Business Review

ADVERTISEMENT

Browse Our Store

Productive Business Dialogue (Simulation)

This simulation will help you learn how to craft conversations that are fact based, minimize defensiveness, and draw out the best thinking from everyone involved.

Measuring Marketing Performance

In many organizations, marketing exists far from the executive suite and the boardroom. Learn how to improve the link between high level corporate strategy and the marketing function.

Management Tip of the Day Enrollment
SPONSORED BY:  

ADVERTISEMENT

Free Downloads

  • Leading Green Blog

    Focused on how to become greener individuals, greener managers, help lead greener organizations, and find new profit and business opportunities through a focus on sustainability.

  • 10 Must-Read Articles from HBR

    If you read nothing else, read these 10 articles from HBR's most influential authors on the essential management topics.

  • Wringing Real Value from IT

    If you stick to three central principles, you can turn IT from a costly mess into a powerful weapon. Brought to you by Microsoft.

  • HBR Answers

    Every day, managers face tough problems and challenges. Working with experts, our editors have identified questions and selected Harvard Business Review articles that will get you the answers to those problems.

  • Free Articles On IT

    Six IT Decisions Your People Shouldn't Make: Learn what they are and how to ensure that IT executive decisions and corporate strategy operate in harmony. Sponsored by Microsoft.